Thanks much! These responses were very helpful. In the end I went with All Star. The additional cost is, to my mind, a bit like insurance: Pay for a known quality and the less likely it is that things go wrong. Will report back!

Hi, I have a question related to All star. i have two quotes for a move from NY to Chicago, one from All Star and the other from another company that get sterling reviews on this site. All star, however, is 2000 bucks more than the other company but will deliver in half the time-lag between pick up ...